
Uptown residents Larry White (left), 76, and Joseph “Jazz” Hayden (right), 70, have both spent decades in prison, and now act as prison activists. (Photo by Nat Rudarakanchana)
On a quiet Friday evening, a band of grizzled but passionate prison activists wound its way through the corridors of Riverside Church, into a bright business-like meeting room. On the agenda this night: the launching of a campaign to end what they call the “New Jim Crow.”
The phrase refers to academic Michelle Alexander’s book “The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness,” which argues that the American criminal justice system is both unjust and racist. Several city-based activists dealing with the rights of prisoners have heard of the book: more than a few highly recommend it, too.
Among those present at this private meeting were two Harlem residents who have endured the prison system for decades and survived to tell the tale.
“We do this and we live this 24/7, all day every day,” said Joseph “Jazz” Hayden, a 70-year-old organizer and activist who had been in prison for 20 years. “But others don’t necessarily know what we’re doing, or know much about the issues we’re dealing with.”
Several of those attending the meeting are associated with the Riverside Church Prison Ministry, a longstanding and well-known prison activist group which receives financial grants from Riverside Church. While the Campaign to End the New Jim Crow is committed to completely transforming what they view as a racist and damaging system of mass incarceration, the regular work of the Riverside Church Prison Ministry involves visiting and writing letters to prisoners, campaigning to strengthen prisoner’s rights, and helping the formerly imprisoned to secure employment and housing.
Common issues here especially pertinent to uptown residents include the disproportionate incarceration of African-Americans and Latinos, as well as the way in which young offenders can quickly become locked into the criminal justice system, often unfairly.
Youths from upper Manhattan account for about 77 percent of Manhattan’s total juvenile detainee population, according to the 2010 New York City Community Snapshots available online.
According to these same community profiles, in all four of the uptown Community Boards – 9 through 12 – more than 90 percent of those incarcerated are either African-American or Hispanic.
As Larry White, a 76-year-old community advocate and policy liaison for the Fortune Society, who was himself imprisoned for 32 years, puts it, “How do we transform a system that we find unbearable?”
Still, it isn’t only uptown residents who care about the rights of the incarcerated. A symposium on criminal justice last month organized by the Think Outside the Cell Foundation, which campaigns for the rights and reputations of prisoners, attracted at least 1,500 people throughout the day from all across the city to Riverside Church. Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer and City Councilman Jumaane Williams of Brooklyn also attended.
“We remain separate and unequal on the streets of New York,” Stringer said at the event, where he spoke about the need to change the widespread police practice of stopping and searching individuals on city streets.
Stringer received a round of applause when he said: “85 percent of those stopped are black or Latino, who are nine times more likely to be stopped than whites. … We cannot wait a minute longer to have a serious conversation about stop and frisk and its collateral effects on our community.”

A sizeable crowd assembles in the morning for the start of the National Symposium on Criminal Justice, held in Riverside Church on Sept. 24. (Photo by Nat Rudarakanchana)
Asked about Chief Judge Jonathan Lipmann’s recent proposals to raise the age at which teenagers in New York are tried as adults instead of juveniles, Stringer agreed that the proposal deserved exploration. He added, “Criminalizing teenagers without an idea of what adult prison looks like is not a good idea.”
New York and North Carolina are the only two states in the nation that try 16-year-olds in adult criminal courts, rather than in family court with juvenile justice punishments.
However, some local activists and residents hold slightly more cautious views on the relationship between criminal justice and upper Manhattan specifically.
Nina Saxon, a community youth activist born and raised in East Harlem, outlined several possible reasons why younger residents of upper Manhattan may be more prone to arrest and incarceration.
“If you look at the demographics of East Harlem, including the unemployment rates, the drug incident rates, and all the arrests, along with the concentration of public housing,” she said, “it makes more sense.
“There are no jobs or training programs. Our youth don’t have any role models: we need real role models who look like us.”
Similarly, after the first official public meeting of the Campaign to End the New Jim Crow, a week after the national symposium, independent consultant Anna Barrow said: “I think people in Harlem are oblivious to these problems. They’ve come to accept these conditions as normal.
“My 36-year-old son talked with friends mostly about plans to end up in prison, instead of talking about plans for employment.
“He also said that being stopped and searched by police has happened to him at least two or three times a week, for 10 years now.”
While Saxon and Barrow are more realistic about the problems faced by uptowners struggling with the criminal justice system, they are nonetheless passionate about fixing what they see as injustices.
Saxon volunteers with the Riverside Church Prison Ministry and teaches women ages 17-62 in Manhattan’s Bayview Correctional Facility. She described the “intense” work as “one of the best things in my life.”
The apparent common factor among these prison activists, who encompass diverse backgrounds and motivations, is visible excitement about recent events, coupled with a commitment to genuine reform, if not revolution, with respect to this country’s criminal justice system.







“who was himself imprisoned for 32 years, puts it, “How do we transform a system that we find unbearable?”
Ummm…guess how you do that? YOU DO NOT COMMIT ANY CRIMES!! Wow. Now was that so hard?
First: there are over 9 million crimes committed and reported every year yet only 1.2 percent of them result in arrest, conviction, and incarceration. “We are all criminals” because you can’t walk out your door and be in the community without violating some rule or regulation. And, laws are enforced on the bases of race and ethnicity and the records and statistics reflect this beyond a doubt. The same people that embedded slavery in the constitution are the same group that is in control today. So, when you say don’t commit crimes how can you when the law was designed to ensnare you and your group? Without law there is no crime, criminals, and need to punish. Your simplistic response has no wings, it can’t fly.
I’m pretty sure that if I stabbed a fellow human being to death during a traffic “dispute” I’d also wind up in prison. I’m equally certain that if I was a ranking member of a drug/money laundering/racketeering organization involved in the sales of illegal narcotics I’d also eventually get caught, convicted, and sent to prison. Race and ethnicity have nothing to do with it. How was the law against murdering a fellow human being “designed to ensnare you and your group”? Are blacks genetically predisposed to killing someone over a traffic dispute? How are the laws against selling illegal drugs “designed to ensnare you and your group”? Are blacks genetically predisposed to selling drugs? Yeah, I didn’t think so.
Nobody forced you to break the law, Jazz. For once in your life why don’t you take responsibility for your actions. The law was never the problem. YOU were the problem. You have control over your actions. Quit blaming the system for your own stupidity. If you know something is illegal, don’t do it.
Hey, JazzHaydenIsAConvictedFelon and wackyliberals, do you guys read articles such as this one just so you can comment and push your “racism doesn’t exist anymore” views and ideas onto others? If you were EDUCATED, you would know how the systems of institutional oppression work. I won’t go into detail about it because you may not grasp it anyway. The truth is quite inconvenient for white folks, which I’m sure you both happen to be. Anyway, racial profiling occurs all the time, the only problem is that if you are not one of the individuals targeted it doesn’t affect you. You don’t even notice it’s happening. So save yourselves from looking foolish in the future and unless you know your history and politics, no one cares what you have to say! Thanks.
It is clear that race plays a huge role in the incarceration of our youth. As an educator I work each day to help my young black and latino boys navigate this system that is working against them, not with them. I worry everyday that one of my young men will get trapped in the system and too many already have. The worst part for me is that we do not help prepare those incarcerated to leave the system when they are freed. We set them up to fail. I know how hard it is to find work and a place to live once you have a record and we must do more to support those that are released in addition to reforming the system that incarcerates them in the first place.